Campus, News, Science & Technology

BU trustees sue Apple, Inc. for patent infringement

A customer using an iPad, one of the many items supposedly in violation of a Boston University patent, at the Apple store on Boylston Street in Boston. PHOTO BY SARAH FISHER/DAILY FREE PRESS STAFF
A customer using an Apple iPad, one of the many items allegedly in violation of a Boston University patent, at an Apple store on Boylston Street in Boston. PHOTO BY SARAH FISHER/DAILY FREE PRESS STAFF

Boston University officials are suing Apple, Inc. and several other smaller technological companies for patent infringement, BU spokesman Colin Riley confirmed.

The Trustees of BU will serve as the plaintiff in the case, alleging that Apple officials illegally used and have continued to use a patent created by electrical and computer engineering professor Theodore Moustakas in 1997, according to a court complaint filed yesterday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. Moustakas’s patent is referred to as the ‘738 patent in the complaint.

“The University is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that Defendant has infringed, and continue to infringe, one or more claims of the ‘738 patent, in violation of [Title] 35 [of the U.S. Code] … among other things, making using, offering to sell, selling and/or importing and/or into the United States without authority or license from the University,” the complaint stated.

The patent, officially titled U.S. Patent No. 5,686,738, or “Highly Insulating Monocrystalline Gallium Nitride Thin Films,” was issued on Nov. 11, 1997. It stands among hundreds of U.S. patents awarded to BU professors.

Several of Apple’s products, including the iPhone 5, iPad and MacBook Air, include a gallium nitride thin film semiconductor device claimed by the ‘738 patent in question, according to the complaint.

Apple officials declined to comment.

The complaint alleged that BU has been damaged by the improper use of Moustakas’ patent, and should therefore receive monetary compensation. The complaint also stated the issue cannot be pled and must go to trial.

BU School of Law Dean Maureen O’Rourke said historically, if a patentee is successful in an infringement claim, courts have been willing to stop the production of the products in violation of the patent.

“A court might be less willing to enjoin the sale of a product if the patented item is a small part of it and instead order a reasonably royalty,” she said in an email. “In either case – injunction or no injunction – a successful plaintiff is likely to be compensated for past infringement. …Patent damages are notoriously difficult to calculate, particularly again when the patented item is a small part of a larger whole.”

However, O’Rourke said due to the nature of the uncertainty of the damages calculation in cases such as the one in question, the patent litigation may settle out of court.

Riley said the complaint speaks for itself and will be resolved through the legal process.

Erik Paul Belt and Kelly Gabos of McCarter & English, LLP, a law firm based in downtown Boston, will represent the Trustees of BU in this case.

7 Comments

  1. Where are the damages?
    BU produces nothing and therefore has no loss of business

    • Wow, why don’t you stand up and scream out I’M A HOPELESS APPLE FANBOY AND I GROVEL AT THEIR FEET. It has nothing to do about loss of business, it’s about another company making profits with your technology.

  2. What a shame! I have 32 (through my revocable trust-filthy rich) young grandchildren, all straight A students and heavily recruited athletes . After hearing this pathetic news, no longer can I allow any to enroll in BU.

    • And you think you and or your grandchildren matter? Welcome to the occupy world….where your “trust fund” is peanuts compared to the royalty’s owed from every device made with their technology.

  3. Pingback: BU trustees sue Apple, Inc. for patent infringement - Daily Free Press (subscription)NEWS

  4. Apple stole? Really? (sarcasm)

    Biggest thieves out there (taxes, warranty, patents), and, ironically, they are also one of the biggest patent trolls out there. Getting a bit of their own medicine.

  5. Pingback: BU trustees sue Apple, Inc. for patent infringement | The Daily Free … | Technology News