I love America. I was born here. I was raised here. And after one marriage and a non-existent battle with alcoholism, I will eventually die here.
After (and while) reading Brian Fudge’s column “Thanks for nothing, England” (Feb. 3, p.7), I was completely appalled. I had to take a break while reading because I had a hard time believing anyone could have the audacity to voice such blasphemy. Brian, you embarrass me, you embarrass yourself.
If you are going to claim American credit for inventing something, at least make a notion as to which part of American culture did invented it. Jazz music originated from black work songs, field shouts and rhythmic elements that are predominantly African — not white Americans. I don’t think you or any other white American can take credit for that, unless you are also willing to take responsibility for enslaving and violating the natural rights of millions of Africans.
“Why do you think we slaughtered all the Indians?” Are you proud of that statement? I know I’m not and I am glad my ancestors were not responsible for that dark shadow of American history. I am proud to have been born and raised in this country, but I am also proud of where my family comes from. If being proud of my nationality makes me a “bad American,” according to Brian Fudge, then I’m OK to be just that.
Being a “good American” does not mean “it’s our duty…to constantly remind ourselves and others how much non-U.S. countries suck,” as Brian Fudge demands. In fact it is the opposite. Yes, America is one of the most powerful countries in the world and, as Brian has stated, in “holding this coveted position comes … a great deal of responsibility.” As Americans, our responsibility is not to be “contemptuous,” but accountable, for our strengths as well as our weaknesses. And yes, Brian, we do have weaknesses.
“We need to fight the good fight.” Is that right, Brian? What exactly is the good fight? Is it a jihad? Or is it a struggle for something we believe in? But wait, isn’t that the same thing?
Gabrielle Hajjar CGS ’09