I am writing in response to Chris Ferruso’s column, “Evil Empire Strikes Back.” While the column does correctly express some of the sources of resentment throughout Red Sox Nation, I must take issue with your assesment of Theo Epstein’s job performance.
All in all, I think Epstein’s done a very good job this offseason, and the critics of the young general manager should back off. Have we not learned anything from last year’s Patriots Super Bowl victory or the Anaheim Angels championship this past fall? There are other ways to approaching success than simply going after the big names.
While you may consider the Red Sox acquistions this offseason “second rate,” they also come at a much cheaper price. The cost of all those players, Mendoza, Timlin, Giambi, Walker, and Mueller combine to roughly the same price that the Yankees are playing Contreras, who along with Matsui have never played a single inning of a Major League game. The only way the Red Sox acquisitions pale in comparison is in the pricetag, which is a good thing in my opinion.
These critics of Epstein are the same critics who blasted Dan Duquette and the previous administration for their short-sightedness. Maybe Jeremy Giambi will play like his brother Jason, probably he won’t, but odds are that he’ll perform a lot better than Tony Clark did last year, and for much less.
Do we really need another Jose Offerman? While the financial constraint of the Red Sox this off season may be frustrating to most fans, I view it as a step in the right direction. The Yankees can and will outspend everybody until they win a championship. Thats just a fact. But every other team has to deal with the reality of a budget. I absolutely would have loved to see Bartolo Colon or Cliff Floyd in a Red Sox uniform next year, but I’m glad they didn’t overpay to get them. Had they overspent now, it would have cost them in the long run. Lets not forget that Pedro Martinez and Nomar Garciaparra could both be free agents after the 2004 season. I realize most fans aren’t looking that far ahead, but its great to see that our young general manager is.
Finally, one last point is much too much is made of Epstein’s age. I don’t put much stock in the report that Epstein smashed a chair after losing out on Alfonzo, (afterall according to one of the New York papers Mo Vaughn was supposed to be traded back to Boston for Tony Clark), and to say that Epstein lost out on Colon because of a lack of maturity is just foolish. He “lost out” on Colon because the Red Sox, rightfully so, were not willing to include Casey Fossum in the deal with the Expos. It had nothing to do with the Yankees, nothing to do with the White Sox, and most certainly nothing to do with Epstein’s maturity.
Maybe in the minds of critics, Epstein hasn’t “won” in December or January. But lets give him a chance, and we’ll see how his critics feel in October while Red Sox Nation is celebrating our first world championship in 85 years.
James Ostis jostis@bu.edu COM 2006 978 479 9502
This is an account occasionally used by the Daily Free Press editors to post archived posts from previous iterations of the site or otherwise for special circumstance publications. See authorship info on the byline at the top of the page.
