More than half of the students in public and private high schools across the nation admitted in a survey to cheating on a test during the past year, an increase ethicists attributed to poor moral guidance during students’ formative years.
In its 2008 Report Card on the Ethics of American Youth, the Josephson Institute, a nonprofit organization dedicated to improving the ethical quality of society, surveyed almost 30,000 students nationwide on their attitudes toward academic cheating.
Josephson Institute Executive Director Rich Jarc said the number of students admitting to cheating has increased at a troubling rate over the past few years.
‘It’s pretty alarming and pretty scary,’ he said. ‘The numbers are so high, I don’t know how much worse it could get.’
Jarc said he worried about the students who continued to cheat through college, saying it does not bode well for the future politicians, cops, corporate executives, parents and other important jobs.
Thirty-eight percent of the high school students who participated in the study admitted to cheating more than twice on exams, while 36 percent admitted to using material from the Internet to plagiarize assignments, up from 33 percent in 2006. The survey also found that one in four of the students admitted to lying on at least one or two questions on the survey.
Despite the high rate of cheating reported, 93 percent of the students in the survey said they were satisfied with their personal character and ethical conduct. Seventy-seven percent declared their actions better intentioned than others.
‘A lot of students cheat because they doubt themselves, and if they see people around having a different answer, they automatically think they’re wrong and other people are right,’ Boston University College of Arts and Sciences junior Elizabeth Majchrzak said.
Boston University philosophy professor Susanne Sreedhar said cheating has significant moral repercussions.
‘Cheating . . . shows a lack of respect for one’s fellow classmates, one’s teacher and one’s school,’ she said. ‘Harsher penalties might well deter cheating, but more importantly, they will send the message that cheating is very wrong.’
Sreedhar said most college students have the potential to improve their ethical standards given guidance.
‘They want to do the right thing, but they often need a push in the right direction,’ she said.
Michael Josephson • Aug 3, 2010 at 2:20 pm
I read with interest.the article in the Daily Free Press on the integrity issues revealed by the Josephson institute study.<p/>As the author of the report I am pleased that you’ve called the issue to the attention of the boston university comunity.<p/>Personally, I think the cheating problem is serious but the fact that 30% of all high school students (in a sample of just under 30,000) stole something from a store in the past year (35% males; 26% females) far more troubling and much harder to explain in terms of pressures on performance.<p/>Though there is huge responsibility for the deterioration of ethics in the adult community, I think it’s dangerous to dismiss either the social or moral significance of the values and behavior patterns of young people simply by locating the blame elsewhere. I also would place greater emphasis on the responsibility and power of this generation to be better than their parents (as they are on environmental issues).<p/>Since the report came out we received great response from the interviews including hundreds of requests concerning the ethical behavior of adults. To provide helpful (though not scientifically valid) data on this question and to stimulate discussion on this important topic we’ve prepared an online survey. <p/>I think it would be instructive and provocative if students, faculty and staff at BU took the test. If you want to see or take the survey just click the link on the home page of http://www.charactercounts.org. <p/>I am working on now and will have up on our website soon a scoring/rating guide that will make the self-test even more interesting. We will send everyone that takes the survey a link to the scoring guide.<p/>Michael Josephson<br/>Josephson Institute of Ethics<br/>www.charactercounts.org<br/>[email protected]<br/>310-846-4800